Product management is a complex world where every decision can have a deep impact on a product's trajectory. One question remains: does a product manager need a strong vision from day one to build a successful product? Let's dive into a topic that still divides the profession.
Product management has become an interdisciplinary field, at the crossroads of business strategy, marketing, engineering and design. In this multifaceted discipline, one of the liveliest debates is about the role of vision in a product's fate.
The strength of a vision from the start
Some people strongly defend the importance of a solid product vision from the outset. For them, vision is a guiding principle that sets the product's direction, the foundation on which every strategic decision rests.
Take the story of Apple, a company that made history thanks to the consistent vision of its charismatic leader, Steve Jobs. His vision of a computer that was easy for the general public to use guided the company's efforts and led to pioneering products like the iPhone and iPad.
That vision was not an afterthought: it was the cornerstone of Apple's product strategy from the beginning. Apple's success shows the power of an early vision, which can inspire teams, attract investors and resonate with customers.
The potential of an evolving vision
Another school of thought believes in the potential of an evolving vision. In this view, an initial vision that is too rigid can box the product manager in and limit their ability to adapt to an ever-moving market.
Slack's journey is one example. The company rose from the ashes of a failed video game project: its founder, Stewart Butterfield, originally wanted to build a multiplayer game, but the project never took off. The team didn't let its initial vision blind it, though, and saw the opportunity in its internal communication tool. It adapted its vision, pivoted, and the rest is history.
Slack's evolution makes the case for an adaptable vision. It shows what a product manager can achieve when they aren't a prisoner of their starting vision and know how to evolve it based on lessons learned and experience.
Examples of product vision: balancing vision and agility
After exploring both points of view, the answer isn't at either extreme but in a balanced approach.
A product manager should start from a broad vision. It's important to have a north star to guide the product's direction, but that vision shouldn't be set in stone. It should stay flexible, adaptable and open to feedback and market changes.
Amazon's vision
Amazon's journey is a classic example of this balance. The company started with the ambition of becoming the largest online bookstore, before widening its vision to everything a customer might want to buy online. That broader vision, “to be the most customer-centric company on Earth,” let it move into very different sectors while still delivering value to its customers.
.webp)
The rise of the “balanced visionary”: a new generation of product managers
In conclusion, the debate isn't about whether a product manager needs a vision from day one, but rather what kind of vision it is. A product manager should be a “balanced visionary”: someone who starts from a vision but is ready to adapt it, evolve it and broaden it based on insights, feedback and market trends.
As a balanced visionary, they know that building a product is rarely a straight path. There are detours, obstacles and course corrections. Building a product isn't about following a script to the letter, but about staying agile and responsive enough to rewrite it when the situation calls for it.
In this permanent dance between vision and adaptability, the product manager doesn't just build a product: they orchestrate a symphony of user satisfaction, business value and market relevance. That symphony may begin with a vision, but its melody is defined by the conductor's ability to adapt to the market's changing rhythms.
So the key to a good product isn't just a strong vision from day one, but the art of being a balanced visionary, able to harmonize vision and agility throughout a product manager's career. To feed that vision with data, discover Screeb's Digital Experience Analytics building block.